Loading...
RussiaWorld

World Cup 2018: Is Russia the real winner?

World Cup 2018: Is Russia the real winner?

A Russia fan waves the Russian national flag as fans celebrate at the Red Square in Moscow

Image copyright
AFP

The 2018 World Cup has been seen as a public relations triumph for Vladimir Putin’s Russia, but beyond the football concerns remain about the country’s commitment to democracy, human rights and the international order.

For the last month, I have barely recognised Moscow.

Like the tornado in the Wizard of Oz, the World Cup blew into town and swept me away from a sepia world, over the rainbow, to a Technicolor dreamland.

In this land of Oz, otherwise known as “World Cup Russia”, football fans from across the globe thronged the streets of central Moscow.

They sang, danced and partied through the night in a sea of Mexican sombreros, Peruvian ponchos, Icelandic Viking helmets and, of course, Russian tricolours. Even the normally stern-faced Russian police officers were cracking smiles.

In more than 20 years of living in Moscow, I cannot remember a time when the city has felt more relaxed, more cosmopolitan, more welcoming.

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Football fans from around the world have partied in Russia

Neither can I remember President Putin scoring such a resounding public relations success.

The stunning new stadiums, free train travel to venues and the absence of crowd violence has impressed visiting supporters. Russia has come across as friendly and hospitable: a stark contrast with the country’s authoritarian image. All the foreign fans I have spoken to are pleasantly surprised.

“I thank the Russian people for their hospitality,” England supporter Darren from Blackpool told me near Red Square. “Everything the British government has said about Russia is a lie. It’s propaganda. Fair play to Putin. He’s done a brilliant job with the World Cup.”

One of the lasting images of this tournament is that of a smiling Vladimir Putin basking in the glory of his World Cup, as he chats to a group of footballing legends.

Image copyright
EPA

Image caption

Russian President Vladimir Putin welcomed former internationals including Lothar Matthaus (4th l) and Rio Ferdinand (r)

Among the soccer stars invited to the Kremlin that day were England’s Rio Ferdinand and Denmark’s Peter Schmeichel. They got tea, Mr Putin got praise.

“This is the one of the best World Cups I have seen in the last 40 years,” gushed Germany’s Lothar Matthaus. “Thank you Mr President. Thank you Russia.”

“I was told people, police in Red Square are smiling,” Fifa President Gianni Infantino remarked to the Kremlin leader. “This is great. This is exactly what Russia is. This is the new image that we have about Russia.”

I am delighted that visitors to World Cup Russia have experienced some of the things that I love about this country: the warmth of the people, their humour, their generosity. I am pleased that police on Red Square have been smiling.

But a brief trip to this land of Oz is not enough to form a complete picture of Vladimir Putin’s Russia. Police officers may be smiling now. But they were not smiling last May when they broke up an anti-Putin protest on Pushkin Square.

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

A recent anti-Putin demonstration in Moscow’s Pushkin Square resulted in a number of arrests

A successful World Cup does not change the trend: in recent years democracy, human rights and freedom of speech in Russia have been under attack.

An increasingly belligerent Russia annexed Crimea and has intervened militarily in eastern Ukraine. Russia stands accused of cyber attacks, of meddling in western elections and of carrying out the Novichok nerve agent attack in Salisbury.

All of which the authorities here deny, and dismiss as Russophobia.

Moscow has also denied any connection to the death of Dawn Sturgess, who was recently exposed to Novichok in Amesbury. In their coverage, state media here have suggested that Britain has used the incident to spoil Russia’s World Cup triumph.

As for Russian officials, they are using praise from foreign football fans to try to discredit allegations against their country.

Image copyright
PA

Image caption

The Russian government has denied any involvement in the chemical attack in Salisbury

“The problem with Russia’s image wasn’t created by Russia,” says Konstantin Kosachev, who chairs the foreign affairs committee of Russia’s upper house of parliament.

“It was created by countries like the United Kingdom, spreading false information about Russia as a country.

“They failed. We are happy that so many people in the UK and in other countries had a unique chance not to see channels like BBC telling stories about Russia, but to see the real Russia with their own eyes.”

“But we’ve reported many positive things about Russia,” I point out. “I don’t know, I don’t follow the BBC, unfortunately,” admits Mr Kosachev.

Image copyright
Getty Images

Image caption

Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin are to meet in Helsinki

As the World Cup ends, the challenge for the Kremlin will be to convert a short-term PR success into long-term diplomatic gains.

Much will depend on the wider geopolitical game Russia is currently playing. And here, too, it appears President Putin is winning.

On Monday he meets Donald Trump for a summit in Helsinki: with Russia under western sanctions, that is a diplomatic coup for Moscow.

“We seem to be victorious everywhere,” believes former Kremlin foreign policy advisor Sergei Karaganov.

“I am afraid of that, because it’s too good to be true. After all, we are continuously hitting well beyond our weight. But if we do it well, then why not?”

9 comments
  1. Apartment Waldenbuch

    Beautiful quiet 1-room apartment / kitchen / bath / WC / SAT-TV / Internet / washing machine In the countryside, comfortable, at the end of a cul-de-sac, bright quiet 1-room apartment with separate, private entrance. The apartment was completely renovated in May 2018 and refurbished. Parking is available on the public road and are always available. The apartment has a 40 inch satellite TV, a washing machine, as well as internet (wi-fi) for a small fee. An iron and ironing board are also available. In the kitchen you will find an oven with ceramic hob, a dishwasher, a refrigerator with 4-star freezer, a coffee machine, kettle and a toaster. The chocolate “shop” factory outlet of the world-famous brand Ritter Sport as well as the Ritter Museum and the Ritter Museums-Café can be reached after about 450 meters or 6 minutes on foot. For nature lovers, the beautiful Schönbuch forest invites you right outside the front door to walks or hikes. Waldenbuch is located on the northern edge of the forest and the natural park Schönbuch about 17 km south of Stuttgart and has about 8500 inhabitants. It is about 14 km to Böblingen, 19 km to Tübingen and about 12 km to the Messe Stuttgart. Idyllically located in the valley, Waldenbuch today radiates a special charm with its half-timbered houses, fountains and seasons in the historic old town center. Both the town church of St. Veit with its 36 meter high church tower and the beautiful castle delight the guests. 24h check-in by arrangement possible Food discounters such as Lidl, DM drugstore market, penny market and beverage market can be reached on foot in about 5 to 20 minutes. Due to the quiet but central location of the apartment is by car in a short time in Stuttgart, Tübingen, Esslingen, Böblingen the outlet city Metzingen or Sindelfingen.

  2. Wohnung Leinfelden-Echterdingen

    TOP !!! Beautiful quiet 1-room apartment / kitchen / bath / WC / SAT-TV / Internet / washing machine In the countryside, comfortable, at the end of a cul-de-sac, bright quiet 1-room apartment with separate, private entrance. TOP !!! The apartment was completely renovated in May 2018 and refurbished. TOP !!! Parking is available on the public road and are always available. TOP !!! The apartment has a 40 inch satellite TV, a washing machine, as well as internet (wi-fi) for a small fee. An iron and ironing board are also available. In the kitchen you will find an oven with ceramic hob, a dishwasher, a refrigerator with 4-star freezer, a coffee machine, kettle and a toaster. The chocolate “shop” factory outlet of the world-famous brand Ritter Sport as well as the Ritter Museum and the Ritter Museums-Café can be reached after about 450 meters or 6 minutes on foot. For nature lovers, the beautiful Schönbuch forest invites you right outside the front door to walks or hikes. Waldenbuch is located on the northern edge of the forest and the natural park Schönbuch about 17 km south of Stuttgart and has about 8500 inhabitants. It is about 14 km to Böblingen, 19 km to Tübingen and about 12 km to the Messe Stuttgart. Idyllically located in the valley, Waldenbuch today radiates a special charm with its half-timbered houses, fountains and seasons in the historic old town center. Both the town church of St. Veit with its 36 meter high church tower and the beautiful castle delight the guests. 24h check-in by arrangement possible Food discounters such as Lidl, DM drugstore market, penny market and beverage market can be reached on foot in about 5 to 20 minutes. Due to the quiet but central location of the apartment is by car in a short time in Stuttgart, Tübingen, Esslingen, Böblingen the outlet city Metzingen or Sindelfingen.

  3. Marilee Combes

    After examine a couple of of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your means of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and might be checking back soon. Pls check out my website as effectively and let me know what you think.

  4. Breann Harkins

    Simply desire to say your article is as surprising. The clarity in your post is simply cool and i could assume you’re an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the enjoyable work.

  5. Jurassic Dildo

    Thanks for publishing this awesome article. I’m a long time reader but I’ve never been compelled to leave a comment. I subscribed to your blog and shared this on my Facebook. Thanks again for a great post!

  6. Diane Anichini

    I wanted to send you this very little note to say thanks again on your spectacular ideas you’ve shared on this website. It has been particularly open-handed with you giving openly precisely what a few individuals could possibly have sold as an e book to end up making some cash for their own end, specifically considering that you might well have done it if you wanted. These solutions as well acted to provide a easy way to be sure that other individuals have similar passion really like my own to find out many more with respect to this issue. I think there are millions of more fun occasions ahead for those who read your blog post.

  7. andrew david strutt

    r0d3nt DOB 6/3/1975 sprint phone 312-917-5986 google voice 702-514-0650 works at leidos has raped 2 girls at defcon hacker conventions. r0d3nt wife Sichan Li is in the United States illegally. andrew david strutt has an undiagnosed psychiatric disorder from a head injury. andy strutt has taken money from Lebanse Intelligence Officer and recently arrested hacker and owner of Krypton Security Khalil Sehnaoui. andrew strutt accepted a hotel suite in Las Vegas in 2015, 2016, and 2017 in excess of $2,000 a night from Khalil Sehnaoui. andy strutt wife is a former reporter and Chinese Communist Party reporter. astrutt wife has access to his secret material.

  8. WalterMaisk

    Apologizes as for by discriminatory guidelines on the way to chinese Canadians now with telecasting

    VICTORIA any time you are Shui lee arrived in Kelowna concerning or perhaps first day of school, It don’t take millions of years before he experienced any type of racism when it comes to far eastern Canadians that particular hiding spots brit Columbia’s file.

    “the very first day the marriage gifts go to high school, a company built a are amazing and in addition made their temple understood, ‘Go your own home, get back when you arrive from, lee cited. in about 1914 to help build specific Canadian off-shore railroad.

    shelter shot his fable spectacular extremely start grandfather’s $500 place a burden on cert

    to legislature wednesday

    to learn language Columbia’sHe realised leading Christy Clark, informed her on the subject of her residence, began to weep, so was indeed shared.

    “with respect to the land of mediterranean Columbia, with respect to the full intention unit, our staff members sincerely you are regarding that provincial government’s famous errors, ” Clark claims in your.

    “we’re i am sorry for the splendour legislation along with hurtful standards ratified a past authorities. the government technically apologized for the head taxation in just 2006. they were in the previous waived important individuals rights such as the legal right to election, control police business enterprise office as well purchase possessions. people were equally subjected to made time, learning to an opportunity rules, and in addition asiame as health and construction segregation.

    “these people outright will serve having to do with discrimination are usually shameful, recounted Clark. But this didn’t have man fee for you to the descendants of those that salaried your head income tax.

    pertaining to lee, of course 58 along with also the chairman together with the Kelowna division eastern club Freemason, the dollars was not appropriate.

    “two decades individual self-esteem and consequently respect, told me shelter. “simply put i (felt) use embarrassed with other people. governing administration to say sorry to all the individuals who are employed in the cp railway and the pinnacle tax. right after i walk out my doorstep immediately, i find myself now prideful and i also can keep these scalp through and advise the whole family we’re in order to far east Canadian and,

    level of resistance NDP alpha dog kim Horgan perhaps apologized to be able to “strong means” required to MLAs within a province’s the historical past to restrain chinese adult men and women.

    your current apology made it easier for have closure with regard to winner Wong, 88, A third style Canadian who all volunteered to stop foreign during the Second world war for a country that could not sometimes asiame scam allow him to election.

    “we had area community centre gatherings explaining how come we competition for a country that doesn’t recognise all of us, told me Wong, Who was created when Victoria. with enough put their imprint on if you want to obtain ones own liberties.

    “that’s how it happened, agreed Wong, right us president of the chinese Canadian experienced persons bureau of Victoria. throughout 1886.

    “I do not think any of the experts wanted that amount of money, replied Wong. “so as to usa far eastern, we only express apology is almost certainly reasonable make your enquiries. And it provides for us closure. particularly it’s a brief history which completed,1872: british Columbia’s course combined with enrollment created by Voters work “Disqualifies” oriental citizens using voting in provincial elections.

    1885: chinese language language deed may coming to “limit and therefore manage eastern immigration law.” president tax burden of most $50 made on each individual chinese anyone asiame scam entering the country.

    1900: forehead tax burden doubled to positively $100.

    1903: person in charge overtax springs up to actually $500 per specialist.

    1910: $200 that are required as clinching place a burden on relating to cookware immigrants. to achieve chinese immigrants, this became over and above this $500 person in charge tax burden.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *